One bench, out of a scrap pile. Three 8 ft studs, one 8 ft 1x4, a 3/4 ply offcut. Screws only, no bought hardware. Longest part is 40 in. Never built. v5 cuts the end rail 1/16 short at each end so it goes in by hand, instead of a taper fit that only a perfect splay would let you assemble.
The end rail was a taper fit. Now it is a cut with a gap in it. v4 cut the rail to the exact clear space between the leg faces: 8-1/2 at its bottom edge, 7-1/2 at its top. That is a wedge and it has to be perfect. Between two legs bevelled by hand, one degree of splay error and the rail will not go in, and the sheet's answer was "recut the ends", which does nothing when the rail is the right part and the space is too small. The rail is now cut 8-3/8 square, and the ends are marked 1/2 in in from the end of the top face and cut down to the bottom corner. Top edge 7-3/8. That leaves about 1/16 clear at each end, and the 5 in screws draw it in. The cut works anywhere from 7-1/8 to 9-1/8 of leg splay, so a foot bevelled by hand cannot make it bind.
The angle became a mark. 8° on a rail end is a gauge reading, and a gauge drifts a degree over 3-1/2 in. 1/2 in in from the end on the flat top face is a measurement with a square and a rule. Same joint, one less way to be wrong.
Nothing else moved. The legs, seat, back and screw count are v4's. The cut plan gains 1/8 in of offcut.
The seat height did not add up. v3 cut the legs 15-1/2 and sat a 3/4 ply top on them: that is 16-1/4, and the sheet kept saying 17. Every number downstream (back top, slat heights) rode on the wrong figure. Legs are now 16-7/16 on the axis, which gives 16-1/4 vertical, and the seat reads 17.
The end rail stopped being a fitted length. v3 said 13-1/2 nominal, fit at assembly to about 12-1/2. A fitted length on a cut list is a hole in a cut list. v4 made it a number, 8-1/2; v5 moves that number 1/8 so it cannot bind.
The post notch is gone. v3 had a 1-1/2 x 3-1/2 notch in the post's lower end, saddling the rear leg. A 1-1/2 x 3-1/2 notch in a 1-1/2 x 3-1/2 post is not a notch, it is the whole end. The post now sits on the seat and is screwed down into the rear apron.
Smaller corrections: the base is 19-1/16 outside to outside, not 21. The slats are 40, flush with the bench ends, not 37. The legs are 3-1/2 deep and 1-1/2 wide along the bench; v3's side view drew them 1-1/2 deep, which contradicted the end rail and the screw length.
| Part | Stock | Cut | Qty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leg | 2x4 | 16-7/16 on the axis. Both ends cut 8° off square, the two cuts parallel. Cut as mirrored front/rear pairs. | 4 |
| Long apron | 2x4 on edge | 37, between the legs, top flush with the leg tops at 16-1/4 | 2 |
| End rail | 2x4 on edge | 8-3/8, cut square, then mark 1/2 in in from each end on the top face and cut down to the bottom corner. Top edge 7-3/8, bottom edge 8-3/8. Goes in about 1/16 clear at each end. | 2 |
| Back post | 2x4 | 14. Top end 15° off square so it sits level at 30-1/2; bottom end 15° off square so it lies flat on the seat. | 2 |
| Back cleat | 2x4 | 14, top end cut 15° flush with the post top. 1-1/2 thick against the post, 3-1/2 wide out to the slat. | 2 |
| Corner block | 2x4 | 3-1/2 long, used flat (1-1/2 thick, 3-1/2 x 3-1/2 face). One in each inside corner. | 4 |
| Back slat | 1x4 | 40 x 3-1/2, ends flush with the bench ends | 2 |
| Seat top | 3/4 ply | 40 x 16-1/2, front edge eased | 1 |
| Stud | Cuts | Used | With kerfs | Offcut |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 37 + 37 aprons | 74 | 74-1/8 | 18-5/8 |
| B | 16-7/16 x 4 legs | 65-3/4 | 66-1/8 | 26-7/8 |
| C | 14 x 4 posts and cleats, then 8-3/8 x 2 end rails | 72-3/4 | 73-3/8 | 19-1/4 |
Kerf counted at 1/8 per cut, so the numbers above already carry it. Corner blocks are 3-1/2 x 4 = 14 in off the end of stud A or C's offcut. Slats: two 40s off the 8 ft 1x4, 16 left over. All 2x4 parts including the blocks come to 226-3/8 against 277-7/8 of stock: 51-1/2 in spare, which is the margin for one leg cut wrong.
Screws: 4 x 5 in, 8 x 3 in, 16 x 2-1/2, 16 x 1-5/8. That is 44 screws and nothing else.
Bottom slat 3-1/2 to 7. Top slat 10 to 13-1/2, its top edge flush with the post tops at 30-1/2. Gap 3 in. This is a lumbar rail and a top rail, not a full back; a third slat is not in the scrap count.
| Check | Should read | If it doesn't |
|---|---|---|
| One cut leg standing on the floor, floor to top face | 16-1/4 (16.25) | The 8° bevel gauge is off, not the cut length |
| Seat height at all four corners | 17, all four within 1/16 | Scribe the feet and take it off the feet. No shims. |
| End rail top edge / bottom edge | 7-3/8 / 8-3/8 | The 1/2 in marks are off; recut the ends, not the legs |
| Clear space between the leg faces at the rail's bottom edge | 8-1/2; 8-3/8 is the floor | Legs are too close. The rail is right. Reset the splay, do not cut the rail |
| Diagonals, each end frame | equal within 1/8 | The frame is racked; loosen the rail screws and re-square |
| Top slat's top edge vs post tops | flush at 30-1/2 | Slat heights are off; move the slat, don't cut the post |
| Outside to outside at the seat line | 40; at the floor 19-1/16 | Leg splay is off |
Nothing here has been cut in wood. I drew it, checked it against itself, and a builder on a forum read v3 and went straight at the end rail: "the fitted end rails are rough on a cut list." He was right, and looking at that line is how I found the 3/4 hole in the height. v5 is the second pass at his line: v4 gave the rail a number, v5 made that number one that a hand-cut frame cannot make fail.
Soft spots I would watch, in order: the bite in the rail's end grain (1-1/2 in with a 5 in screw, pilot 1/8); the 45° post screws, which need a pilot and a steady hand; the 8° bevels on the legs, which is the one operation where a hand saw and a gauge will drift; and the rail's 1/2 in marks, which are easy to mark on the wrong face.
If a line here doesn't add up, name it and I'll change the sheet, not the story.
v4 drawn 2026-11-13, v5 2026-11-15. All dimensions in inches. Every dimension line on the drawing is generated from the same geometry the tables come from, so a label cannot disagree with the shape it measures.